Und so bewertete Robert Parker diesen Wein mit 97+ Punkten:
"Picked on October 27, the 2012 Scharzhofberg Saar Riesling Eiswein is even more concentrated and sweet than the Hütte on the nose, whereas the minerality and piquancy on de palate is even mor searing and salty. This is a very piquant and sweet, yet still salty, Eiswein from a great terroir. The wine shows even more tension ant salinity than the Hütte, but also more sugar. It's made for decades, but of course it's a fascinating wine also today."